Quick answer: We pulled the list price on all 765 paddles in our database that carry one, and expensive pickleball paddles do not measure the way the price tags imply. Almost the entire measurable gain happens between the sub-$100 shelf and roughly $120. Above about $150 the curve goes flat: paddles in the $200–$249 band actually score lower on power than the $100–$149 band, and average weight is effectively identical across every price bracket. There is a real but modest spin premium at the very top — for roughly three times the money.
The 30-second version
- 765 paddles with a list price, from a $13.59 wood paddle to a $350 flagship.
- The only real cliff is at the bottom. Under $100, average spin is 5.69. In the $100–$149 band it is 6.43. That one step is bigger than everything above it combined.
- Above $150 the curve flattens. Power does not climb with price — the $200–$249 band is the weakest of all five.
- Both rating sources agree independently, which is why we trust the shape. We re-ran every number separately on John Kew’s scores and on Pickleball Studio’s.
- The top of the market does buy some spin — highest of any band on both scorecards — but you are paying about $150 more for it.
- Weight is flat across every band (226.6g to 228.4g). Money buys you nothing here at all.
- Prices are not actually rising. Average list has sat between $186 and $208 every year since 2021.
- The value zone is $100–$150, and it is crowded — 119 paddles.
Every few weeks somebody at open play hands me a paddle and asks whether it is worth upgrading. It is a hard question to answer honestly, because the honest answer is not the one the pro shop gives. We have specs and third-party scores on 781 paddles, 765 of which list a price, so rather than guess I ran the numbers. What the list prices show is a curve with one steep step near the bottom and a long flat stretch after it.
Do expensive pickleball paddles actually measure better?
Here is the whole catalogue, cut into five price bands. Power and spin are the aggregated 0–10 third-party scores described at the bottom of this piece.
| Price band | Paddles | Avg list | Power | Spin | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $100 | 56 | $93 | 5.67 | 5.69 | 227.2g |
| $100–$149 | 119 | $130 | 5.82 | 6.43 | 226.9g |
| $150–$199 | 299 | $180 | 5.72 | 6.24 | 228.4g |
| $200–$249 | 164 | $230 | 5.55 | 6.39 | 226.6g |
| $250 and up | 127 | $283 | 5.90 | 6.38 | 228.1g |
Two things jump out. The step from the under-$100 shelf into the $100–$149 band is worth about three-quarters of a point of spin — far and away the largest move in the table. And after that, nothing much happens. Power wanders between 5.55 and 5.90 with no relationship to price at all, and the $200–$249 band comes in lowest of the five.
That power dip is not a glitch. Paddles in that bracket skew heavily toward control-oriented builds aimed at advanced players, and a softer, more controlled paddle is exactly what a lower power score describes. It is a reminder that a higher number is not automatically a better paddle — it is a different paddle. If you want the power end specifically, our power paddle picks sort for that directly.
Does the finding survive a second opinion?
This is the check that matters, and it is the one that has quietly broken catalogue comparisons for us before. Our scores come from two independent reviewers who test differently, and they are not evenly spread across price bands — the cheap end skews toward one reviewer, the middle toward the other. If you ignore that, the mix itself can manufacture a trend.
So we re-ran the table twice, once using only paddles scored by John Kew and once using only paddles scored by Pickleball Studio. The conclusion held both times. On spin, from the under-$100 band to the $100–$149 band:
- Kew-scored paddles only: 5.74 → 6.58, then essentially flat through the middle bands (6.51 and 6.64).
- Studio-scored paddles only: 5.81 → 6.30, then 5.78 and 6.01 in the middle bands.
Two reviewers, two methodologies, same shape: one real step at the bottom, then a plateau. Where they disagree is on the size of the premium at the very top, so we are not going to pretend to a precise figure there.
What does the top of the market actually buy you?
Some spin, and not much else. The $250-and-up band posts the highest spin figure of any band on both scorecards — 6.91 on Kew’s, 6.16 on Studio’s. That is a genuine edge, and if you play a heavy topspin game at a level where it pays, it is defensible.
What it is not is a transformation. You are spending roughly $150 more per paddle than the value band for a fraction of a point on a ten-point scale, on a paddle that weighs the same and does not hit harder. And the top of the market is concentrated: of the 127 paddles at $250 or more, 33 are JOOLA and 28 are Selkirk or Selkirk Labs — 48% of the premium shelf from two brand families, with Engage, Gearbox and CRBN accounting for most of the rest.
The most expensive paddles in the database also illustrate the limits of price as a signal. Several of the $333 Selkirk Labs Project paddles score in the 4s and 5s on Studio’s ten-point scale — one of them scores a 1.0. Those are small-batch experimental releases rather than mainstream flagships, so it is not quite a like-for-like comparison, but it does make the point: at the top of the market you are frequently paying for limited production, not measured performance.
Are paddles getting more expensive?
No — and this surprised me. Average list price by release year has been remarkably stable: $192 in 2021, $208 in 2022, $186 in 2023, $197 in 2024, $208 in 2025 and $207 across the 89 paddles we have dated to 2026. Five years of noise inside a $22 range.
The thing that has changed is the floor. The cheap shelf is much better than it used to be, which is precisely why the sub-$100 to $100–$149 step shows up so sharply: below $100 you are still largely buying older fibreglass and entry composite construction, and just above it you are into raw carbon faces. That is a construction boundary that happens to sit near a price boundary. For what is genuinely good below the line, we keep a separate list of budget paddles under $100.
Which paddles sit in the value band?
These are not picks in the sense of a ranked roundup — they are simply the paddles in the $100–$149 band that score well on the axis their marketing claims. Three of them come from brands that give our readers a code, which is disclosed below.
- Franklin FS Tour Dynasty 16mm — $149.99. The highest power score in the entire band, and it grades well on both reviewers’ overall scores. Franklin is also the rare New England company in this catalogue, headquartered in Stoughton, Massachusetts.
- Volair Mach 2 Forza 16mm — $119.99. One of the better-rounded paddles under $120 on Studio’s scoring, with a strong spin figure.
- Vatic Pro V-sol Pro Bloom — $109.99. A control-leaning build that scores above its price bracket.
- Luzz Glider 2026 — $129.00. An 8.4 spin figure, which is top-tier at any price, let alone this one.
- Honolulu Sword & Shield J5 — $149.85. Sits at the top of the band on power.
- Ronbus R1.16 — $100.00. Exactly on the line and still posting a 7.6 spin score.
If you would rather filter on your own game than take a list, the paddle finder ranks all of them against how you actually play, and every model has its own page in the full database.
What this data cannot tell you
Plenty, and it is worth being straight about it:
- These are list prices, not street prices. Paddles get discounted constantly. A $250 paddle at 30% off changes the arithmetic entirely.
- The scores are not ours. They come from Pickleball Studio and John Kew, who test independently on their own 0–10 scales. We aggregate and link back; we do not average the two scales into a single number.
- Coverage is uneven. Not every paddle has every score — spin figures exist for 44 of the 56 sub-$100 paddles and 85 of the 127 premium ones. The bands are large enough for the pattern to be meaningful, but individual band figures carry different confidence.
- Feel is not in the table. Grip shape, balance, swing weight, how the handle suits a two-handed backhand, whether it is quiet enough for your town’s courts — none of that is a number here, and all of it matters more to most players than a tenth of a point.
- Durability is not in the table either. A cheaper face that loses its grit in a season is not the bargain it appeared to be.
So the practical read: if you are playing on something under $100, an upgrade into the $100–$150 band is the single best-supported spend in this entire data set. If you are already there, the case for going further is about feel, shape and specific preferences — not about the numbers, which stop rewarding you. Go demo before you spend; most New England clubs in our court directory have loaners.
Disclosures. Regan Family Pickleball has ambassador arrangements with several paddle brands, including Volair, Vatic Pro and Honolulu Pickleball Co., which give readers a discount code and may earn us a commission. Jason is also a Selkirk Advocate and has received discounted Selkirk product; Selkirk is named here only in the brand-concentration count. None of these relationships affect the ratings quoted, which are third-party and independent of us. Current codes are on our gear page. Paddle specifications and prices are as listed by manufacturers and were accurate when this was written.
Written by Jason Regan, who runs Regan Family Pickleball out of Leominster, Massachusetts and maintains our database of 781 pickleball paddles.
Related reading: what paddle weight actually does · Kevlar faces · fibreglass faces · under $100 · the paddle finder